Powered By Blogger

Friday, February 11, 2011

Issue 7 Critique

PAPER
Praise:

  1. I liked the layout on Exploring the Unconscious.  The drawings caught my attention and made me want to read the story.  The article didn't look so long that I might get bored reading it, and the subtitles made me wonder what exactly this article was about.  After reading The Dream, it was no doubt that I would read the rest and find out where it would go from there.
  2. I liked the main spread of this issue.  It was a nice idea seeing as though Valentine's Day is Monday.  It was spaced out so that it wasn't cluttered, but there wasn't too much white space either.  There was plenty of room left for the ads as well, which were big enough to catch someone's attention as well, making it more likely for people to use the coupons.



Constructive Criticism:

  1. I didn't really like the picture that was used in Right Down the Lane.  I think I would have chosen to get a picture of the girl as she was bowling so that we could see that the story was about that.  When I saw the picture I wasn't sure what the article was going to be about.
  2. When I saw the cover page of the newspaper, my first thought was that there was going to be a feature article on kids needing to be healthier and how obesity is affecting everyone.
  3. The UMKC ad seems to be in there every time.  I know that money is received from using their ad, but seeing the same one over and over again loses the interest of people and then it's as if it's not even there because it always looks the same.



ONLINE EDITION
Praise:

  1. The main story when you go to the main page is the rivalry story.  The lead into this story was good, causing me to click and read the rest of the story.  After reading the article, I noticed the links that were included and read a few of those too.
  2. My attention was caught when I looked at the pole archive.  It's interesting to know what people think, even if it's the simplest questions.  A lot of the time, there's a majority of people for one answer so that line that extends much further than the others can be eye-catching.



Constructive Criticism:

  1. When scrolling down on the home page for the paper, I just see a lot of words.  I think there should be more pictures or graphics to catch people's attention.  The quotes from stories is nice, but when you see it for majority of the page, it all just starts to blend together.
  2. The Photos of the Week should be updated more often.  The main slideshow on that page are pictures from last semester.  There could be some from this week of students showing off their spirit, or pictures from basketball games too.
  3. When I was looking at the entertainment tab, there was only one graphic, aside from the poll on the side, and it was lacking color or design.  

No comments:

Post a Comment