Powered By Blogger

Thursday, February 24, 2011

CE x 3 First Amendment Articles

Journalism Shield Law Important for Hawaii, First Amendment

This CE includes the following elements of newsworthiness:
  1. Audience- because it would be of interest to journalists and people involved with journalism
  2. Policy- because it gives the people in Hawaii more freedom and they need to know about it

Summary: Hawaii is now the 37th state to enact a shield law, which protects journalists for some of the information they use in their writing.  This law makes it so that they do not have to testify as to what their sources are.  Protection of journalists and reporters is important because without that safety, sources would be less likely to give out information to reporters.

Reaction: I think it's important for reporters and journalists to have this shield law because without this form or protection, we probably wouldn't get as much information as we do since people with information would be less willing to give it out knowing they could be testified in court for it.  It's good to see that majority of the states have chosen to enact this shield law and hopefully the number of states will increase so that it can be fair.

Kan. Neighbor Feud Sparks Free-Speech Debate

This CE includes the following elements of newsworthiness:
  1. Proximity- because it's here in Kansas, not that far away from where we are
  2. Impact- because they are getting national coverage from this
Summary: In Wichita, there is a man who has been disrespectful to another woman and her family.  He has repeatedly spoke rude and insulting comments regarding her and her family.  She has tried to get the city to issue a restraining order, saying that he tried to poison her cats and hit her with his vehicle.  The signs that he has displayed on his house have become a big deal.  Neighbors are embarrassed and there are worries about property values decreasing.

Reaction: I understand that this is a first amendment issue, but there are some times where people just take it too far.  This man has no reason to be making rude comments and gestures to this woman and her family.  I think the city could figure out something that they might be able to do to convince this man that what he has done is unnecessary and disrespectful.

Tenn. Bill Equates Islamic Law with Treason

This CE includes the following elements of newsworthiness:
  1. Conflict- between the court and people with religion
  2. Policy- because it's a new law being introduced
Summary: State lawmakers in Tennessee have proposed a bill that says following the Islamic code can be charged as a felony punishable by 15 years in jail.  Some people have called it nonsense, and there has been consideration to amending the bill.

Reaction: The state doesn't necessarily have the right to pass such a bill.  Those people are only being a part of what their religion does and one of the specific freedoms in the first amendment is religion so it doesn't get more straightforward than that.  The state legislature is taking away one of this group's first amendment freedoms, which isn't right.

1 comment:

  1. Your third reaction paragraph is your strongest. Notice it doesn't use phrases like "I think" and "I understand," which are used in the first two reactions. Avoid these phrases.

    ReplyDelete